This week, the Court addresses the definition of
“financial advisory services” under the Consumer
Financial Protection Act and whether a plaintiff's
allegations of First Amendment violations plausibly stated a claim
under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12(b)(6).
CONSUMER FINANCIAL PROTECTION BUREAU
V. ARIA
The Court holds that a defendant's business, which
advertised itself as a targeted program for helping students apply
to scholarships, constituted “financial advisory
services” covered by the Consumer Financial Protection Act
(CFPA) and was deceptive in violation of the Act.
The panel: Judges Graber, Tallman, and
Friedland, with Judge Tallman writing the opinion.
Key highlight: “Aria is incorrect that
scholarships are not financial in nature merely because they do not
have to be repaid. As discussed, the ordinary meaning of financial
is broad and encompasses both cash financing and debt financing.
Indeed, the definition of ‘finance'