On June 22, 2017, the Wisconsin Supreme Court took a 3-Iron to
common intuitions about who is, and who is not, a dealer protected
by the Wisconsin Fair Dealership Law (WFDL). In Benson v. City of Madison, 2017 WI
65, the Court found that four golf pros—clearly not your
typical dealers—were protected by the WFDL, meaning that
their contracts for managing Madison's golf courses could not
be terminated by the City, absent statutorily defined "good
cause."
Among WFDL cases, Benson is indeed significant. In
holding that the WFDL can apply to municipalities, the Court opened
up wholly new relationships to WFDL protection. And the Court's
ultimate conclusion—that the relationship between the
municipality and the golf pros constituted a "dealership"
under the WFDL—was also reached without a clear application
of the rigorous community of interest analysis seemingly required
by the Court's own prior case law. These holdings have
potentially far-reaching consequences, both for