To win, trial lawyers must master the art of persuasion. But
when they lose, they are tested by their mastery of the art of
preservation. As standards of review in appellate courts have
become increasingly demanding, preservation often requires
coordination with your appellate attorney.
It used to be safe for trial lawyers to preserve
"issues" for appeal. Appellate lawyers could then refine
those issues with more detailed arguments in their briefs. But
increasingly, appellate judges are rejecting this approach. The
evolution began in criminal cases. For example, the Florida Supreme
Court in Steinhorst v. State, 412 So. 2d 332, 338 (Fla.
1982) held that an "argument" was not
"cognizable" unless "the specific contention"
was argued in the trial court. Now, even civil appeals in Florida
are often rejected because the "specific" legal argument
was not made below.