"Related Claims" provisions in directors and officers
(D&O) and errors and omissions (E&O) policies, while
common, can spawn disagreement as to scope and application. Beyond
these substantive questions, an issue arises as to what information
a court may consider in determining whether two or more claims are
"related" within the meaning of a given policy. The
Eleventh Circuit recently analyzed this issue in
Health First, Inc. v. Capitol Specialty Insurance
Corporation, No. 17-11181 (11th Cir. Aug. 22, 2018).
In Health First, the insured (Health First, Inc.), a
Florida health care company, obtained D&O and E&O
claims-made policies from various insurers, including Executive
Risk Indemnity Inc., Executive Risk Specialty Insurance Co.,
Capital Specialty Insurance Corp., Darwin National Assurance Co.,
and Darwin Select Insurance Co. Each policy contained a
"related claim" provision, which generally provided that
"[a]ll Related Claims, whenever made, shall be deemed to be