Party Cannot Appeal Decision That District Court Did Not Make Regarding Motion To Vacate Arbitration Award

The Sixth Circuit has declined to rule on a motion to vacate an arbitration award, which was brought at the same time as a successful motion to dismiss the action for forum non conveniens, when the district court had not decided that motion. The Court found that no exceptional circumstances existed that would justify ruling on an issue not addressed by the district court and that, given its other ruling, the district court was correct not to address the motion.

The case was initially brought in federal court in Tennessee by Milan Express, which alleged various claims against Applied Underwriters relating to an agreement to provide workers' compensation coverage. The parties later agreed to submit the matter to arbitration, but the arbitration panel determined that the arbitration clause in the parties' agreement was unenforceable. Returning to federal court, Applied Underwriters filed two motions: a motion to dismiss for forum non conveniens and a motion to vacate