The Supreme Court of Ohio reinforced the "Sham-Affidavit" Rule and affirmed a judge’s rejection of an expert affidavit that contradicted the expert's previous report. In Moore v. Mercy Medical Center, the court held that a "sham affidavit," even if authored by an expert, cannot create genuine issues of fact.
In a 5-2 decision, the Supreme Court affirmed a Fifth District Court of Appeals decision that dismissed a lawsuit accusing doctors at Mercy Medical Center of committing malpractice during the birth of a child. The Court’s decision addressed the “sham-affidavit” rule, which is designed to help a trial court determine whether a case can be resolved on summary judgment without proceeding to trial.