Despite the judicial hierarchy of a state's appellate
court, its power to review and correct errors made by a trial court
is based on standards of review that serve to establish a
deferential approach. The standards foster the creation of a stable
body of legal precedents intended to guide the trial courts in
addressing substantive and procedural law.
This article presents a comparison of New York and New
Jersey's appellate standards of review on pain and suffering
awards in medical malpractice actions.
Standards of Review
New Jersey, like most jurisdictions, applies a highly
deferential standard of review and the appellate court assesses
whether a damages award shocks the judicial
conscience (Cuevas v. Wentworth Group, 226 N.J. 480,
488 [2016]). New York, however, has a distinctive feature in that
it modified its standard of review through enactment of N.Y. CPLR
Section 5501(c), which evaluates whether a damages
award deviates materially from what would