Megyn Kelly and other Fox News commenters did not defame a
Wisconsin firefighter when they said it was "not right,"
"disgusting," and a "fraud" that he
"exploited [a] supposed injury" to collect disability
benefits "for life," according to a recent Wisconsin
Court of Appeals decision. The court found these comments to be
"simply a collection of opinion statements based on fully
disclosed ... substantially true facts" and therefore not
actionable under Wisconsin defamation law. The court's ruling
is an unusually strong statement of support for the right to
comment on issues of legitimate public interest, even when the
commentary is "sarcastic, belittling and impolite."
The case, Marjala v. Fox News Network LLC, No.
2015AP1831 (Dec. 20, 2016), arose from news media reports on a
North Shore Milwaukee firefighter, Aaron Marjala, who received duty
disability benefits because of an ulnar nerve (funny bone) injury,
but went on to compete in ironman triathlons and to