Fourth Circuit Instructs District Court To Vacate Arbitration Award That Was Not Mutual, Final, And Definite

The Fourth Circuit reversed and remanded the district court's order granting Norfolk Southern Railway Company's motion to confirm an arbitration award determining the amount Sprint must pay to Norfolk Southern for continued use of railroad rights. Under the parties' contract, because the parties' respective appraisers disagreed as to the proper amount, a third appraiser was instructed to arrive at a compromise with one (or both) of the other appraisers. Ultimately, the third appraiser agreed with the amount set forth by Norfolk Southern's appraiser, but conditioned his assent to the award subject to two conditions- (1) that Norfolk Southern had marketable title and (2) that the value used by Norfolk Southern's appraiser was reasonable. The third appraiser also reserved the right to withdraw his assent if his assumptions proved to be incorrect. The AAA panel found that this decision constituted a final and binding arbitration award, which upon Norfolk Southern's