On August 11, 2017, the New Jersey Superior Court, Appellate
Division held, in Kevin Dugan and Roman Zielonka v. Best
Buy Co. Inc., and Garrett Hetrick, Docket No. A-1897-16T4,
that when it comes to employers implementing new arbitration
policies for any disputes with its employees, continued employment
alone may not be explicit, affirmative assent to arbitrate
claims.
Like all contracts, arbitration policies require mutual
agreement and consideration between employer and employee.
While New Jersey courts have held continued employment is
sufficient consideration for some employment-related agreements,
the Appellate Division was clear that consideration is a concept
and element of contract formation which is different from mutual
assent, which was the concept at issue in Dugan v. Best
Buy. Consideration requires each party give something up
to the other to bind them to the agreement while mutual assent
requires each party agree.