Earlier this week, I joined "Air Talk" on KPCC radio
for a discussion of the California Supreme Court's recent
criminal decisions, beginning with People v. Gutierrez, in which
the Court reversed three convictions for the first time in many
years based upon Batson/Wheeler (strikes from the jury pool based
on minority status) error. So I thought we'd turn our
attention to the issue we discussed – is the California
Supreme Court turning in a more liberal direction in criminal
cases?
In Table 221, we show the absolute numbers – the cases
defendants have won, the partial affirmances and reversals, and the
cases defendant have lost. For the first half of our period,
defendants have won ten or more cases only four times – 1996
(11 wins); 1999 (15 wins); 2002 (11 wins) and 2005 (14 wins).
The defense won nine cases each in 2000, 2001 and 2003. In
1998 and 2005, they won eight cases per year. In 1994 and
1997, they won five cases each year. In 1995, they won