Your client has brought you an appeal, and you quickly spot what
looks like a winning argument. Unfortunately, it was never raised
or argued below. Being a savvy appellate lawyer, you understand you
cannot raise it for the first time on appeal. Time to move on,
right? Not always.
In Lopez Ventura v. Sessions, --- F.3d ----, 2018 WL
5093238 (5th Cir. Oct. 19, 2018), the Fifth Circuit Court of
Appeals granted relief to Manuel Lopez Ventura, based on a specific
argument that was raised for the first time on appeal.
The short backstory is this. Lopez Ventura pleaded guilty in
Louisiana to possessing AB-CHMINACA, a synthetic cannabinoid. After
his conviction, he left the country, but later returned and applied
to be admitted as a lawful permanent resident. By administrative
order, the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) found him to be
inadmissible, reasoning that AB-CHMINACA was a controlled substance
on the date of his conviction in Louisiana. As it turns
out,