The US Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit reversed an
award of enhanced damages even while affirming a jury finding of
willfulness (based on substantial evidence), explaining that the
award was not adequately explained by the district court.
Polara Engineering Inc. v. Campbell Company, Case Nos.
17-11974, -2033 (Fed. Cir. July 10, 2018) (Lourie, J). The Court
also found that substantial evidence of experimental use trumped
any public use bar.
Polara sued Campbell for infringement of its patent directed to
a two-wire, push-button control system for crosswalk stations for
pedestrian use at signal-controlled intersections. Polara's
Pedestrian Accessible Signal System (APS) produced visual, audible
and tactile signals. Prior to the critical date, and subject to
agreements with a municipality that did not include a
confidentiality clause, Polara tested two prototypes that satisfied
the limitations of the asserted claims. The early installation
prototypes failed, and