The US Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit vacated a
district court's denial of attorney's fees, finding that
voluntary dismissal with prejudice constituted a final judgment for
the purposes of FRCP Rule 54(d) under Ninth Circuit law. Keith
Mfg., Co. v. Butterfield, Case No. 19-1136 (Fed. Cir. Apr. 7,
2020) (Hughes, J.).
In 2015, Keith Mfg., a company specializing in loading and
unloading trailers, sued a former employee, Mr. Butterfield, in
district court. The lawsuit accused Butterfield of patent
infringement and alleged that he had improperly obtained a patent
application based on inventions made during his employment.
Butterfield's patent covered a device for unloading trailers.
Butterfield sent Keith Mfg. a covenant not to sue on the patent and
then filed a motion to dismiss all but the correction of
inventorship claims. The district court dismissed the declaratory
judgment claims but allowed the state court claims to proceed. In
2017, the parties reached a