While attending his friend’s wedding at the Trump National
Golf Club in New Jersey in June 2017, Jonathan Otto took a
photograph of a certain wedding crasher: the president himself.
Otto texted the photo to his friend, Sean Burke, another guest
at the wedding. By the next morning, the image had gone viral and
ended up on TMZ, CNN, the Washington Post, the Daily Mail, and a
Hearst Communications’ publication, Esquire. Apparently,
Burke had sent the photo to Linda Piatowski (a relative of the
bride), she had posted it on Instagram, and the media outlets
copied it from there.
The day after the media outlets published the photo, Otto
registered it with the Copyright Office and filed suit in federal
court (the Southern District of New York) against the media outlets
that had published it. Everyone settled except Hearst. In a recent
decision, the court rejected Hearst’s defenses across the
board, finding instead that a media outlet cannot poach a
photograph from social