An Eastern District of Texas jury has returned a noninfringement
verdict for AT&T in a case from
Atlantic IP Services plaintiff Daingean
Technologies Limited, in which Nokia and
Ericsson had intervened as the manufacturers of
the accused cellular base stations. The verdict follows another
trial that went for the plaintiff in July, a different East Texas
jury awarding $2M against Deutsche Telekom
(T-Mobile) in a suit where Nokia and Ericsson also
intervened.
Daingean sued AT&T in March 2023, followed by T-Mobile that
July. The original complaints in both cases asserted six patents
(8,576,803; 10,484,976; 10,841,958; 10,932,207; 11,134,400;
11,196,509) received from two sources: Mitsubishi
Electric (MELCO), which assigned five patents to Daingean
in August 2022; and FG Innovation Company Ltd.
(f/k/a FG IP Innovation Company Ltd.) (FGI), which later added
seven to Daingean's holdings. In August 2023, the plaintiff
also sued Apple; that case ended in November