Medtronic Inc. v. Boston Scientific Corp.
The U.S. Supreme Court has granted a writ of certiorari in a
license dispute involving licensed defibrillator patents in which a
DJ plaintiff (Medtronic) held a license that gave it the right to
challenge the licensed patent even while under license. In this
case, the licensee (Boston Scientific) held an exclusive license in
the patents. Medtronic Inc. v. Boston Scientific Corp.,
Docket No. 12-1128 (Supr. Ct., 2013).
Normally, a patentee has the burden of proving infringement.
Here, when Medtronic challenged whether its new products infringed
the patents in question, the Federal Circuit reversed the burden
and held that where a licensee sues for a declaratory judgment of
non-infringement, it has the burden of proof on infringement. (See
IP Update Vol. 15, No. 10.) In its cert. petition,
Medtronic posed the following question: