We have previously written about how the Federal Circuit and the
PTAB are applying the AIA estoppel provisions.1 Since
the Federal Circuit's Shaw ruling, several recent
opinions have construed the scope of estoppel. Two of these cases,
from district courts, cases have applied estoppel narrowly. But a
recent PTAB decision, issued in the wake of these decisions, shows
that the Board is not following the lead of the district courts,
but instead is continuing to apply its broad approach to estoppel.
It will likely be left to the Federal Circuit to resolve the
difference, although the Court of Appeals recently declined an
invitation to take on the issue.
Key Takeaway: There is a split of
authority between the district courts and the PTAB regarding how
narrowly or broadly to apply estoppel after a final PTAB decision.
Based on the narrow scope of estoppel applied by the courts to
date, parties should be prepared to litigate in court any
invalidity grounds not actually