In Google LLC v. Ecofactor, Inc., Nos. 2022-1750,
2022-1767 (Fed. Cir. Feb. 7, 2024), the Federal Circuit reversed
the Patent Trial and Appeal Board's ("Board")
construction, vacated the Board's Final Written Decision, and
remanded for further proceedings under the correct
construction.
U.S. Patent No. 8,498,753 relates generally to climate control
systems, such as heating and cooling systems. Following institution
of the IPR, the Board found Google failed to prove the challenged
claims unpatentable and in doing so, stated that claim construction
was unnecessary although it interpreted a claim limitation
implicitly.
First, the Federal Circuit held that the Board, in its analysis,
implicitly construed a claim limitation, establishing the scope and
meaning of the patented subject matter. That the Board stated that
it did not construe claims was not dispositive. Next, the Federal
Circuit held that the Board's claim construction did not
violate the Administrative