In its third opportunity to review the district court's
decision in this trade secret case involving flooring, the US Court
of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit again reversed, this time
vacating a permanent injunction and an award of attorneys'
fees. The Eleventh Circuit noted that the district court failed to
make the findings required to support an injunction and abused its
discretion in awarding full fees notwithstanding prior reversal of
relief awarded. AcryliCon USA, LLC v. Silikal GmbH,
Case No. 21-12853 (11th Cir. Aug. 29, 2022)
(Newsom, Marcus, JJ.; Middlebrooks, Distr.
J.)
In an
earlier appeal in this case, the Eleventh Circuit reversed a
ruling on trade secret misappropriation rendered by the district
court in favor of AcryliCon USA (AC-USA) and vacated the damages
award. An aspect of the Court's ruling was that the
"permanent" injunction entered by the district court was
only preliminary in nature (not permanent) and was, as a matter of
law, dissolved