2019 was a busy year for § 101, with decisions covering a
wide range of issues including diagnostic methods, covered business
methods, abstract ideas and even mechanical claims.
USPTO Guidance
The USPTO's Patent Eligibility Guidance update in
January 2019 caused quite a stir among practitioners when they
split Step 2A of the Alice/Mayo test into two prongs.
After a lengthy comment period (and an increase in allowance of
patents facing § 101 issues), the Office released an update to its 2019 PEG, clearing
up five areas of confusion (
IP Update Vol. 22, No. 11). First, the Office
clarified that a claim may impliedly "recite" a
judicial exception without explicitly reciting the exception (as
was the case in the patent claims in Alice). Second, the
2019 PEG distilled the previous case law-based grouping of abstract
ideas into three general categories: mathematical concepts, methods
of organizing human activity and mental processes. The October
Update provided