Plaintiff Freight Tracking Technologies recently suffered a
setback in its patent infringement suit against APM Terminals North
America, Inc. In its suit, Freight Tracking alleges that two
"automated" ports operated by APM—one in
Portsmouth, Virginia, and the other, "Pier 400," near Los
Angeles, California—practice the GPS-enabled container
tracking methods of two of its patents. Freight Tracking recently
moved to compel production of technical specification documents
related to Pier 400, owned and operated by a wholly-owned
subsidiary of APM, arguing that APM is liable for the
subsidiary's infringement.
Magistrate Judge Douglas E. Miller denied Freight Tracking's
effort to secure the subsidiary's documents, citing Federal
Circuit authority holding that a parent corporation may only be
liable as a direct infringer under 35 U.S.C. § 271(a) for
infringement by its subsidiary where "the evidence reveals
circumstances justifying disregard of the status of