In re Steed et al.
Addressing the requirements for antedating a prior art reference
(for a pre-AIA patent application), the U.S. Court of Appeals for
the Federal Circuit affirmed the decision of the Board of Patent
Appeals and Interferences that a table which purports to associate
a date with a piece of evidence, but does not explain how the
evidence corresponds to conception or reduction to practice, is
insufficient to establish a date of invention or actual or
constructive reduction to practice. In re Steed et al.,
Case No. 14-1458 (Fed. Cir., Oct. 1, 2015) (Newman, J.).
A group of inventors filed and prosecuted, pro se, an
application for a "Web-Integrated On-Line Financial Database
System and Method for Debt Recovery." During prosecution, the
examiner rejected all of the claims as obvious in view of a
published patent application (Evans) alone or in combination with
other references. After unsuccessfully arguing that the claimed
invention was distinct from