Fair Wind Sailing, Inc. v. Dempster, 764 F.3d 303 (3d Cir.
2014)
Two Virgin Islands sailing schools hit some choppy water
recently when one school sued the other. Fair Wind Sailing (Fair
Wind) alleged that its former employees, H. Scott Dempster and
Larry Bouffard, copied its business in many respects when opening
their competing sailing school, Virgin Island Sailing School
(VISS). This copying, according to Fair Wind, amounted to trade
dress infringement. Fair Wind identified its trade dress as the
combination of its use of catamaran vessels, a unique teaching
curriculum, student testimonials, and its registered domain
name.
The similarities between the schools' businesses are
striking. VISS uses only 45-foot catamarans, just like Fair Wind.
Additionally, the junior school uses identical teaching curricula,
itineraries, and student feedback procedures to those used by Fair
Wind. Web marketing for both schools is also identical. VISS even
included on its website a