Copyright Act Does Not Apply to Proposed Sale of Allegedly
Unlawful Copy of Sculpture to US Buyer Because All Relevant Conduct
Occurred Outside the US and No Infringing US “Predicate
Act” Otherwise Exists
Noland v. Jannsen, US District Court for the
Southern District of New York, March 8, 2019
Plaintiff Cady Noland is an artist whose work includes a wooden
sculpture in the form of the façade of a log cabin. The work
had been placed outdoors and the owner replaced many of the parts
that had deteriorated from exposure. The defendants, two German art
galleries, the owner of one of the galleries, and a German art
collector, tried to sell the repaired work, and Noland sued them
for copyright infringement and other violations of law, claiming
the existing sculpture was an “unauthorized copy” of
the original.