In a non-precedential decision, the US Court of Appeals for the
Federal Circuit concluded that the degree of teaching away is a
question of fact reviewable for substantial evidence, and affirmed
a determination of obviousness in an inter partes review.
Gold Standard Instruments, LLC v. US Endodontics, LLC,
Case No. 16-2597 (Fed. Cir., Aug. 17, 2017) (Prost, CJ).
Gold Standard is the owner of a patent directed to methods for
manufacturing an endodontic instrument by heat-treating the entire
shank of the instrument. US Endodontics filed a petition for
inter partes review of the patent. The Patent Trial and
Appeal Board (PTAB or Board) found all claims of the patent obvious
in view of a reference by Matsutani, which discloses a procedure
for heat-treating three-quarters of the shank of an instrument.
However, Matsutani discloses that "a problem may occur"
in the manufacture of an instrument if the maker heat-treats more
than three-quarters of the shank. In arguing around