In Phytelligence, Inc. v. Washington State
University, the Federal Circuit held that the agreement
terms at issue constituted “an unenforceable agreement to
agree” that did not convey the license rights at issue. While
decided under state law, this decision highlights the potential
unenforceability of options clauses that do not specify sufficient
terms of the option that may be exercised.
The Agreement At Issue
The agreement at issue was a “Propagation Agreement”
that gave Phytelligence the right to propagate “WA 38”
apple trees, which the Federal Circuit opinion describes as
“a new apple cultivar that WSU developed and patented.”
The dispute focused on Section 4 of the agreement, and whether it
gave Phytelligence the right to sell WA
38 trees, or whether it was a mere agreement to agree to a future
license to do so.