With the Supreme Court in Oil States v. Greene’s
Energy holding IPRs constitutional under Article III, and the
Federal Circuit in Celgene v. Peter holding the retroactive use of IPRs against pre-AIA
patents not to be an unconstitutional taking, litigants have
recently tested the constitutional viability of the Patent Trial
and Appeal Board (PTAB).
We previously, in a blog post, highlighted an Appointments Clause
challenge to PTAB judges in another still-pending case, Polaris
Innovations Ltd. v. Kingston Tech. Co., No. 18-1768. As of
this writing, Polaris has not yet been decided, argument
before the Federal Circuit set for Monday, November 4. But the
Federal Circuit has finally spoken on the issue, in Arthrex,
Inc. v. Smith & Nephew, Inc., No. 18-2140 (decided Oct.
31, 2019). (The Appointments Clause issue in
Polaris is the same as in Arthtrex.)