Corning Inc. v. DSMIP Assets B.V.
The Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) issued final written
decisions in 10 inter partes review (IPR) challenges.
Although early IPR decisions generally have sustained
petitioners' challenges, here the PTAB largely sided with the
patent owner, upholding 157 out of 209 challenged claims spanning
across eight related patents. Corning Inc. v. DSM IP
Assets B.V., Case Nos. IPR2013-0043 and IPR2013-0044 (PTAB,
May 1, 2014) (McKelvey, APJ); IPR2013-0045 (PTAB, May 9, 2014)
(Obermann, APJ); IPR2013-0046 (PTAB, May 1, 2014) (Bisk, APJ);
IPR2013-0047 (PTAB, May 1, 2014) (McKelvey, APJ); IPR2013-0048
(PTAB, May 9, 2014) (Kamholz, APJ); IPR2013-0049 (PTAB, May 9,
2014) (Kamholz, APJ); IPR2013-0050 (PTAB, May 1, 2014) (Kamholz,
APJ); IPR2013-0052 (PTAB, May 1, 2014) (Yang, APJ); IPR2013-0053
(PTAB, May 1, 2014) (Yang, APJ).