Addressing when Illinois law's “absolute litigation
privilege” bars certain counterclaims, the US Court of
Appeals for the Federal Circuit affirmed a district court's
summary judgment finding that the plaintiff lacked a valid trade
dress and reversed the district court's decision that
declined to apply the absolute litigation privilege as a complete
defense to all of the alleged infringer's
counterclaims. Toyo Tire Corp v. Atturo Tire Corp.,
Case No. 22-1817 (Fed. Cir. Oct. 4, 2024) (Moore,
Clevenger, Chen, JJ.) (nonprecedential).
Toyo and Atturo are competitors in the tire design business.
After perceiving widespread copying of its tire designs, Toyo filed
a district court action asserting design patent infringement and
trade dress infringement against Atturo. Atturo asserted
counterclaims, including false designation of origin under the
Lanham Act and several state law counterclaims. The district court
eventually dismissed with prejudice Toyo's design