Introduction: The Centrality of Conception
In patent law, conception is the cornerstone of inventorship.
For pharmaceutical companies, where billions in revenue hinge on
patents for molecules, formulations, and methods, getting
inventorship right is mission critical. A misstep in identifying
inventors can render patents invalid, expose the company to
litigation, or weaken exclusivity positions.
Conception of Molecules: Fixing the Structure
For a new chemical entity, conception requires a definite and
permanent idea of the chemical structure. Conception does not occur
unless one has a mental picture of the structure of the chemical,
or is able to define it by its method of preparation, its physical
or chemical properties, or whatever characteristics sufficiently
distinguish it. Fiers v. Revel, 984 F.2d 1164, 1168 (Fed. Cir.
1993). The inventor must have mentally fixed the compound, such
that one skilled in the art could synthesize it without undue
experimentation.