On October 24, 2016 the Ninth Circuit joined the Third, Fourth,
Fifth and Sixth Circuits in applying the fee-shifting ruling of
Octane Fitness LLC v ICON Health & Fitness Inc, 134 S Ct 1749
(2014), to a Lanham Act case – SunEarth Inc v Sun Earth Solar
Power Co, DC 4:11-cv-04991-CW (9th Cir 2016).
The 2014 Supreme Court decision in Octane Fitness overturned the
Federal Circuit's standard for determining when a case is
"exceptional" under 35 USC §285, adopting a flexible
"totality of the circumstances" analysis and lowering the
standard of proof to establish entitlement of fees from "clear
and convincing evidence" to a "preponderance of the
evidence". While Octane Fitness was a patent law decision, the
Lanham Act and Patent Act both limit the award of attorney fees to
"exceptional" cases. The SunEarth decision brings the
total to five circuits that have held that the Octane Fitness
standard should apply for determining an "exceptional"
case brought pursuant to the