As discussed
here, the en banc Federal Circuit vacated and remanded the
PTAB's decision in Aqua Products, Inc. v. Matal,
determining that the PTAB erred in placing the burden of persuasion
on the patent owner for proposed claim amendments. Four judges on
the eleven-judge en banc panel dissented, and would have upheld the
PTO's rule, 37 C.F.R. § 42.42(c), that places the burden
of persuasion on the moving party, and agreed with the PTO that
this rule applies to patent owners who move to amend claims during
an IPR.
In particular, Judge Taranto, writing in dissent and joined by
Chief Judge Prost and Judges Chen and Hughes, concluded that 35
U.S.C. § 316(a) authorizes the PTO to issue rules concerning
which party has the burden of proving the patentability of proposed
substitute claims, and that 35 U.S.C. § 316(e) does not
unambiguously bar assigning that burden to the patent owner. In
evaluating the PTO's rule, Judge Taranto applied the two-step
framework under Chevron