Beauty is in the eye of the beholder is a catch phrase well
known and of ancient origin. Benjamin Franklin even had a wry turn
at it in Poor Richard's Almanack, 1741:
"Beauty, like supreme dominion is but supported by
opinion." As it turns out, however, in the opinion of
the District Court of Delaware, "beauty," or in this
case, enhancement of the skin is not a term one ought to have in
their patent claims, because that which relies on opinion is
indefinite in the eyes of the court. Univ. of Mass. and
Carmel Labs., LLC v. L'Oréal
Inc., D.Del. (April 21, 2021).
University of Massachusetts sued beauty product manufacturer
L'Oréal for infringement of its U.S. Patent numbers
6,423,327 and 6,645,513 for a method of using adenosine to
"enhance[e] the condition of unbroken skin of a mammal by
reducing one or more of wrinkling, roughness, dryness, or laxity of
the skin." Putting aside the matter of what other
mammalian species besides our own would shell out good money