The United States Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit,
applying Florida law, has held that letters from an insured company
explaining the basis for termination of its CEO and President and
requesting that he preserve documents and return company equipment
did not constitute a "claim" because they did not include
a demand for monetary relief or any other legal remedy. Scott v. Certain Underwriters
at Lloyd's London, et al., 2025 WL 2443382 (11th
Cir. Aug. 25, 2025). The court also held that the
correspondence was not a valid "notice of circumstances"
per the policy's terms.
The plaintiff was terminated from his role as CEO, President,
and Secretary of the insured company after a failed attempt to
purchase the majority interest held by the insured's
controlling investor. After his termination, the former officer
threatened legal action against the insured entity, which responded
with a series of letters accusing the former officer of misconduct,
demanding that he