A Magistrate Judge in the U.S. District Court for the Southern
District of New York has recommended that a default judgment
totaling more than $221 million be entered against the Islamic
Republic of Iran and in favor of insurers who paid claims to their
insureds for property damage, business interruption and other
losses arising out of the terrorist attacks on 9/11. In doing so,
however, the magistrate also recommended denying the insurers'
application for an additional $305 million reflecting payments made
under reinsurance contracts.
The plaintiff-insurers argued that they were entitled to all
amounts they were compelled to expend under applicable policies of
insurance and reinsurance resulting from 9/11. The court concluded,
however, that the insurers were only entitled to recover under the
doctrine of subrogation. The court explained that subrogation
allows an insurer to "stand in the shoes" of its insured
for purposes of seeking payment from third-parties whose