On July 1, 2020, Michigan Circuit Court Judge Joyce Draganchuk
issued what it appears to be to be the first U.S. court decision in
an insured's first party property lawsuit against an
insurance carrier seeking business interruption coverage as a
result of a governor's shelter-in-place order. See
Gavrilides Management Company v. Michigan Insurance
Company. The insurer filed a motion for summary
disposition asking the Michigan Court to rule as a matter of law
that its policy did not provide coverage for business interruption
losses caused by COVID-19 shelter-in-place order. Judge Draganchuk
agreed with the insurer. The hearing on the motion is posted on You
Tube.
View Here
Michigan Insurance Company argued that the policy provided
coverage only for direct physical loss of or damage to the
insured's properties and noted that missing from the
insured's Complaint was any allegation that the property had
been damaged. Rather, the insured only focused on the
governor's