Liability policies cover sums an insured becomes legally
obligated to pay to a third-party as damages for a loss. Typically,
there is no coverage in a liability policy for expenses incurred by
the insured to repair damage to the insured’s own property.
Additionally, nearly every liability policy has an owned-property
exclusion. In a recent case, the 5th Circuit addressed this subject
and whether an exception to the owned-property exclusion
applied.
In Eagle Water, L.L.C. v.
Ash, No. 19-30056 (5th Cir. Sep. 26, 2019) (unpublished),
the owner of a sewer system repaired that system following a
localized collapse and sought to recover the cost of repair from
its liability insurer. The insurer paid for property damage
suffered by a homeowner when the sewer system backed up because of
the collapse, but rejected the policyholder’s request to
cover the cost for repairing the sewer system. As the court noted,
without those repairs, there could have been additional backups