In a matter of first impression, the Fifth Circuit upheld a
dismissal by the Northern District of Texas holding that a lender
cannot be held vicariously liable for a loan servicer’s
purported violation of the Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act
(“RESPA”). In upholding the decision, the Court held
that the borrower failed to plead an agency relationship, and that,
even if an agency relationship existed, the lender could not be
held vicariously liable as a matter of law for the servicer’s
alleged failure to comply with RESPA. In reaching its decision, the
Fifth Circuit relied upon a plain reading of RESPA, which imposes
duties only on loan servicers and restricts liability to those who
fail “to comply with any provision” of RESPA.