In a searing and trenchant per curiam opinion
(Coalition for Responsible Regulation et al. v. EPA, No.
09-1322, June 26. 2012), the U.S. Court of Appeals for the DC
Circuit unequivocally denied all challenges to EPA's
greenhouse gas (GHG) regulations, setting the stage for a potential
rematch of the parties before the Supreme Court.
Numerous companies, trade associations and states had filed
challenges to various aspects of the EPA's actions and
rulemakings. The opponents challenged EPA's finding that
GHGs (including CO2, methane and four other compounds) were
collectively an "air pollutant" that potentially
endangered human health and the environment ("Endangerment
Finding") as well as, its regulation of GHG emissions from the
automotive sector through the "Tailpipe Rule" and its
limitation of the scope and impact of regulating GHG emissions from
stationary sources through the Timing and Tailoring Rules.