Share on LinkedInShare on LinkedIn

ARTICLE · 14 DECEMBER 2022

ERISA: Ninth Circuit — Why Denial Letters Must Include All Rationale To Be Asserted In Litigation

Can a district court consider new arguments justifying claim denial that were not articulated in the initial claim denial or appeal? NO. In fact this new Ninth Circuit decision...

United StatesEmployment and HR

Can a district court consider new arguments justifying claim denial that were not articulated in the initial claim denial or appeal? NO. In fact this new Ninth Circuit decision indicates for the first time that it is "clear error" for a district court to adopt "newly presented rationale when applying de novo review."

Even rationale focused on a claimant's credibility must be affirmatively stated in the claim denial, if considered, or it will be deemed a "newly presented rationale" and must be excluded from consideration by the district court if asserted in the litigation.

Here's the newest case that highlights the point: Collier v. Lincoln Life Assurance Company of Boston, __ F.4th __ (9th Cir. November 21, 2022)("[District court clearly errs by adopting newly presented rationale (for denying a Long Term Disability claim) when applying de novo review.")

We operate a free-to-view policy, asking only that you register in order to read all of our content. Please login or register to view the rest of this article.

See more popular content from