Overruling its 23-year precedent, the Ninth Circuit, sitting
en banc, held that to avoid dismissal under the False
Claims Act's (FCA) public disclosure bar, relators need not
have participated in the public disclosure of alleged fraud to
qualify as an "original source." Although the court's
decision concerned the pre-2010 version of that bar, it is likely
that its reasoning will also apply to the post-2010 version, given
that the issue before the Ninth Circuit did not turn on the 2010
amendments.
U.S. ex rel. Hartpence v. Kinetic Concepts, Inc.
consolidated two FCA complaints brought by former employees against
Kinetic Concepts. The complaints alleged that the company
improperly submitted reimbursement claims using an automatic
payment modifier code for medical devices that improve wound
healing, even though the claims required individual review.
The alleged fraud was already publicly disclosed. Thus, the
FCA's public disclosure bar precluded the suits unless