Applying Delaware law, the Superior Court of the State of
Delaware has held that a bump up provision did not bar coverage of
a settlement that resolved claims asserting breaches of fiduciary
duty. Viacom Inc. v. U.S. Specialty Ins., 2023
WL 5224690 (Del. Super. Ct. Aug. 10, 2023).
On December 4, 2019, the insured media company merged with
another media company. Stockholders brought several lawsuits
challenging the merger and asserted claims for breach of fiduciary
duty against the insured's directors, officers, and controlling
stockholders for their roles in negotiating and recommending the
merger. Specifically, the plaintiffs in the underlying litigation
alleged that one director exerted control over other directors,
stockholders, and officers, causing them to approve the merger on
terms detrimental to the insured company. Those terms facilitated
that director's preferred candidate to be CEO of the newly
formed company, which allegedly led to a valuation of the