U.S. District Judge Cathy A. Bencivengo recently dismissed a
plaintiff's TCPA putative class claim due to lack of standing
required under Article III. In Anton Ewing v.
SQM US, Inc. et al., No. 3:16-cv-1609-CAB-JLB (S.D. Cal.,
Sept. 29, 2016), the plaintiff alleged that he received a single
survey call made by SQM on Blue Shield's behalf via an
automated telephone dialing system without his consent. In
addition to his individual claim, the plaintiff sought class
certification for individuals similarly situated within four years
prior to the filing of the complaint.
The claims in this case are important to companies similarly
situated to Blue Shield and SQM because opportunistic litigants
seek recovery without injury. The decision applied
Spokeo's requirement for a plaintiff to establish
"concrete harm" in order to maintain Article III standing
to assert a TCPA claim. Earlier this year, Spokeo
clarified the Article III standing requirement, finding that a