Share on LinkedInShare on LinkedIn

ARTICLE · 29 OCTOBER 2026

A Recent SDNY Decision Sets Up A First Amendment Test For Personalized Pricing Laws

Frankfurt Kurnit Klein & Selz PC
Frankfurt Kurnit Klein & Selz PC
Contributor
Frankfurt Kurnit Klein & Selz PC

Frankfurt Kurnit Klein & Selz PC

Founded more than 40 years ago as a boutique law firm servicing the entertainment and arts...

View firm profile
Explore more from Frankfurt Kurnit Klein & Selz PC

A federal court in New York has preliminarily enjoined a provision of the state's rent-setting law, ruling that algorithmic pricing recommendations constitute commercial speech protected by the First Amendment. This decision in RealPage, Inc. v. James could have far-reaching implications for personalized pricing laws nationwide, as courts now must apply intermediate scrutiny to regulations that restrict pricing recommendations generated by software.

United StatesConsumer Protection

Arecent decision from the Southern District of New York signals that personalized pricing (often called surveillance pricing) laws face First Amendment headwinds. The case is RealPage, Inc. v. James, Case No. 25-cv-09847.

On September 29, Judge Valerie Caproni preliminarily enjoined a provision of New York’s new rent-setting law. The provision made it unlawful for landlords to set rents based on recommendations from software performing a “coordinating function.” The plaintiff, a software vendor providing those recommendations, challenged the law.

While this case looks like it’s about a niche rent regulation dispute, it’s also about algorithmically driven pricing recommendations. The plaintiff’s software analyzes data and recommends rents, i.e., prices, to landlords setting those rents. The court held that these recommendations are commercial speech, even though software generates them, and that the plaintiff is likely to show the provision fails the intermediate scrutiny that applies to commercial speech. The court called its decision a “close call.”

Many pricing tools work the same way. The ripple effects of this decision could reach the personalized pricing laws and class actions we’ve covered extensively on our blog, for example in this mid-year roundup of new laws, update on the emergence of class action theories, and post on the FTC’s surveillance pricing report. The laws most exposed, at least under this decision, are those that potentially restrict pricing recommendations, whether by regulating the vendors who supply them or the businesses that act on them, e.g., New York’s One Fair Price Act.

Although RealPage is a preliminary ruling involving an antitrust-style statute, its reasoning goes beyond allegedly collusive rent-setting. With courts treating an algorithm’s pricing recommendation as commercial speech, a law that restricts that recommendation must survive intermediate scrutiny, which requires a reasonable fit between the law and its goals. Whether personalized pricing laws hold up under that test remains to be seen.

With courts treating an algorithm’s pricing recommendation as commercial speech, a law that restricts that recommendation must survive intermediate scrutiny, which requires a reasonable fit between the law and its goals.

www.fkks.com

This alert provides general coverage of its subject area. We provide it with the understanding that Frankfurt Kurnit Klein & Selz is not engaged herein in rendering legal advice, and shall not be liable for any damages resulting from any error, inaccuracy, or omission. Our attorneys practice law only in jurisdictions in which they are properly authorized to do so. We do not seek to represent clients in other jurisdictions.

See more popular content from