We continue to take notice of recent antitrust litigation
activity in the healthcare industry involving specialty and
physician-owned hospitals. In one such case, four
Dayton-area hospital systems and their shared managing agent,
Premier Health Partners, moved to dismiss a specialty
hospital's complaint that alleged a conspiracy to orchestrate a
per se illegal group boycott. Seeing no need for oral argument, an
Ohio federal judge refused to dismiss the complaint.
Medical Center at Elizabeth Place (MCEP), a 26-bed acute-care
hospital located in Dayton, Ohio, alleged violations of Section 1
of the Sherman Act, including claims that defendants conspired to
prohibit managed care providers, representing more than 70 percent
of Dayton area insureds, from contracting with MCEP and to provide
financial incentives for physicians who refused to work with MCEP
and financial consequences for those physicians that did.
Defendants moved to dismiss the complaint on three grounds: