In June 2014, the DOJ announced that it planned to review the
consent decrees with music licensing firms ASCAP and BMI.
These consent decrees were initially entered in 1941; the
ASCAP consent decree was last amended in 2001 and the BMI consent
decree was last amended in 1994. The DOJ asked for comments concerning whether the
consent decrees "need to be modified to account for changes in
how music is delivered to and experienced by listeners."
On August 6, ASCAP and BMI filed public comments regarding
the consent decree review.
ASCAP argued that "[t]he market place for music . . . is
changing dramatically," with "[n]ew technologies"
such as Pandora, Spotify, and iTunes Radio "quickly surpassing
physical music sales and digital downloads in popularity."
As a result, ASCAP urged that the consent decree needs to be
modified to allow ASCAP members to enter into direct licenses
through arms' length transactions at market value, to provide
for clear guidance to the