1. GENERAL NEWS
1.1. Conditions to be satisfied for a discovery assessment to
be valid
Anthony While succeeded in overturning a discovery assessment
made by HMRC, arising from his receipt of a substantial award for
damages from his former employer for an incorrect reference and
wrongful dismissal.
When Mr While was a director of an insurance company he ran up
debts with HMRC in excess of £150,000, but agreed a repayment
plan to settle the liability. This was interrupted in 1992 when he
was dismissed. As a result of an Industrial Tribunal hearing and
then a High Court claim, Mr While received in excess of
£354,000 as compensation and damages. The High Court decision
stated that the amount to be received by Mr While was net of all
taxes. However the Court (and the advisers to the Court who
prepared the schedule of loss) had omitted to take account of the
fact that the award in excess of £30,000 should be subject to
income tax. The award had not been declared on Mr