"Pay without set-off or counterclaim" provision fails to prevent statutory demand being set aside.
Garrow v Society of Lloyd's (Judgment October 13, 1999)
Lloyd's served a statutory demand on Garrow in respect of an undisputed judgment debt. Garrow was also party to a class action against Lloyd's alleging fraudulent misrepresentation. If successful, the likely damages would exceed the amount of the judgment debt. He applied to have the statutory demand set aside on these grounds.
Garrow's contract with Lloyd's provided that sums were due "...in all respects free and clear from any set-off, counterclaim or other deduction on any account whatsoever...". It went on to provide that, in connection with his obligation to pay, no cause of action could accrue in favour of Garrow and that he was prohibited from issuing any proceedings himself, until he had paid all sums due under the contract.