Management of investment trusts: VAT exempt
The European Court of Justice has released its judgment in the case of JPMorgan Fleming Claverhouse. The Court, following the Advocate General’s opinion, concluded that management services supplied to investment trust companies (ITC) in the UK should be exempt from VAT – and indeed, should always have been.
Current UK legislation restricts the VAT exemption to the management of authorised unit trusts and open-ended investment companies, but, with this ruling, it breaches the principle of fiscal neutrality. Taxpayers are now able to rely on the fact that the Sixth Directive has direct effect.
A number of businesses have already lodged protective claims and are eager to press HM Revenue & Customs (HMRC) for their refunds. However, some questions remain. If ITC management services should always have been exempt, then HMRC can claw back any input VAT recovered on such operations, and reject claims if they do not take account of the reduced